Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement Rate Increase History: Iowa Records, Older Filings and 2027 Outlook

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 27, 2026

Key Takeaway

Physicians Mutual’s Medicare Supplement rate increase history has turned sharply upward: Iowa’s state records show its post-2010 plans rising 9% in 2023, 12% in 2024 and 15% in both 2025 and 2026, after a 2013 filing that asked for no increase on most plans. Its sister company Physicians Life took 22.9% in Iowa in July 2026, so check which company issued your policy before you renew.

2027 by the Numbers

15%

Physicians Mutual post-2010 plans, Iowa, April 2026 (Iowa Insurance Division)

22.9%

Physicians Life modernized plans, Iowa, July 2026 (Iowa Insurance Division)

0%

Increase proposed for most plans in the 2014 D.C. filing (SERFF PHYS-129280129)

A+

AM Best rating after a November 2025 upgrade from A

Physicians Mutual has sold insurance out of Omaha, Nebraska since 1902, and its Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans are marketed heavily by phone and online. Shoppers often see a low first-year quote. The harder question is what that quote turns into after three or four renewals.

Few states post carrier-by-carrier Medigap rate histories. Iowa does, by form number, so we pulled its records, an older public D.C. filing and published summaries for the newest affiliate to show the pattern.

Compare Physicians Mutual with other Medicare Supplement companies

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Three Companies Behind the Physicians Mutual Name

The three Physicians Mutual companies that issue Medicare Supplement policies: Physicians Mutual, Physicians Life and Physicians Select

Your policy may not actually say Physicians Mutual Insurance Company. The group writes Medigap coverage through three insurers, and each one files and prices its own rates:

✔
Physicians Mutual Insurance Company (NAIC 80578) holds the older blocks, including plans sold before June 2010 and its first post-2010 plan forms.
✔
Physicians Life Insurance Company issues Medigap plans in many states today. Maryland’s 2026 rate guide, for example, lists Physicians Life as the company behind the Physicians Mutual website.
✔
Physicians Select Insurance Company (NAIC 17414) is the newest affiliate and focuses on Plan G, including the Innovative Plan G version.

Because the blocks are separate, one affiliate can post a modest change while another posts a large one in the same state and year. Your rate letter names the issuing company.

What Iowa's Rate Records Show for 2022 to 2026

Physicians Mutual and Physicians Life Medicare Supplement rate changes listed by the Iowa Insurance Division, 2022 to 2026

The Iowa Insurance Division’s report of standardized Medicare Supplement rate changes, dated July 13, 2026, lists each Physicians company by form number and effective date. It does not say whether any change was cut from a larger request.

For Physicians Mutual’s post-2010 plans (forms P020, P025, P026 and P027), every listed plan rose by the same amount each April: 9% in 2023, 12% in 2024, 15% in 2025 and 15% again in 2026. Its older agent-sold forms (the P620 series) moved more slowly, with changes of 0% to 5% in 2023, 7.5% to 9.5% in 2025 and 9% in 2026.

Physicians Life’s numbers climbed faster. Its modernized post-2010 forms rose 6% in July 2022, 9% in 2023, 14% in 2024, 15% in 2025 and 22.9% in July 2026. Physicians Select’s Plan G forms in Iowa list 14% for January 2025, 22.7% for October 2025 and 19% for October 2026.

Two dates in 2025? Physicians Select certified to Iowa that no policyholder gets a second increase within a year of the last one.

See Medicare Supplement prices for your ZIP code

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Physicians Mutual Filings Side by Side

No single public source lines up the group’s filings across states and companies. We built this table from Iowa’s report, a D.C. regulator’s posted filing and published summaries citing CSG Actuarial data:

State Effective Company / plans Change Source
D.C. Apr. 2012 Physicians Mutual, 1990-era plans 4.2% overall Listed as prior revision in D.C. filing
D.C. Apr. 2014 Physicians Mutual, Plans A, B, C, F, J 0% proposed SERFF PHYS-129280129 (D.C. DISB)
D.C. Apr. 2014 Physicians Mutual, Plan G About 6% proposed Same filing (rate tables)
Iowa Apr. 2026 Physicians Mutual, post-2010 plans 15% Iowa Insurance Division
Iowa July 2026 Physicians Life, modernized plans 22.9% Iowa Insurance Division
Iowa Oct. 2026 Physicians Select, Plan G 19% Iowa Insurance Division
Texas Jan. and Sept. 2025 Physicians Select, Plan G 11%, then 17% Reported from CSG Actuarial data
Tennessee Jan. and Nov. 2025 Physicians Select, Plan G 9.9%, then 25% Reported from CSG Actuarial data
Pennsylvania Oct. 2025 Physicians Select, Plan G 9% Reported from CSG Actuarial data

In that 2014 D.C. filing, Physicians Mutual wrote that its experience did not call for an increase on most plans. A decade later it was taking double-digit increases in Iowa every year.

From a No-Increase Year to Double Digits

Timeline of Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement rate changes from the 2012 revision to the 2026 Iowa increase

Put the records in order and the shift is clear. Around 2012 to 2014, Physicians Mutual’s changes were small: a 4.2% overall revision in 2012 and a proposal of no change on most D.C. plans for 2014. By 2023 the post-2010 plans were rising 9% a year, and the step-ups kept getting larger through 2026.

Physicians Mutual is not alone in raising rates; claims rose market-wide after 2022. What stands out is how fast its newer affiliates moved to some of the largest increases in the filings we found.

For 2027: We found no published 2027 percentages for any Physicians company yet. Physicians Mutual’s Iowa changes take effect in April, so 2027 figures may not surface until early spring. Plan for another increase.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

Attained Age, Issue Age and Innovative Plan G

How your policy is rated changes how hard each increase hits. Maryland’s July 2026 guide lists Physicians Life as “Attained Age/Issue Age”: Plan A is issue-age rated, the other plans are attained-age, and issue-age rates are available for all plans. Under attained age, your premium also climbs with each birthday, separate from the general increases above.

The 2014 D.C. filing shows the company has long mixed methods. Plans A, B, C and F were attained-age, Plan G was issue-age and Plan J used banded issue age.

Innovative Plan G carries a deductible in its first three calendar years and is not shown on Medicare’s plan finder, so it is harder to compare. To see how rating methods affect lifetime cost, read our guide to Medicare Supplement plans cost.

What Four Years of Iowa Increases Add Up To

Compounding is where rate history really bites. Applying Iowa’s listed changes for Physicians Mutual’s post-2010 plans in order (9%, 12%, 15% and 15%) gives a combined rise of about 61% between early 2023 and April 2026. A plan that cost $150 a month before the 2023 change would cost roughly $242 after the 2026 one, or about $1,100 more per year. That $150 is an illustration, not an actual Physicians Mutual rate. In an attained-age policy, add four years of age steps on top.

AM Best’s November 2025 report said earnings dipped mainly because of statutory strain from new Medicare Supplement sales, with a corrective plan in place. Federal rules also require individual Medigap policies to pay out at least 65% of premiums as claims, so rising claims lead directly to rate filings. Compare carriers in our overview of Medicare Supplement rate increases.

Financial Strength and Discounts

Rate increases are not a sign of weak finances here. In November 2025 AM Best upgraded Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and Physicians Life Insurance Company to A+ (Superior) from A (Excellent), citing the strongest level of risk-adjusted capital and the group’s new mutual holding company structure. Some reviews still show the old A.

Household savings are solid. Maryland’s guide shows a 10% household discount for Physicians Life, and NerdWallet found roughly 11% in the markets it priced, with a roommate counting as well as a spouse. See how that stacks up in our Medicare Supplement household discount guide.

When the Physicians Mutual Rate Notice Arrives

1
Find the company name on the notice. Physicians Mutual, Physicians Life and Physicians Select each have their own history, so look up the right one.
2
Ask whether issue-age rates exist for your plan. If you’re healthy, an issue-age version of the same plan can remove future age steps.
3
Check for a birthday rule. Several states where Physicians Mutual sells, including Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Oklahoma and Virginia, let you change plans around your birthday without full underwriting.
4
Price two or three rivals with steadier records. Same plan letter, same benefits, so only premium and rate trend differ.
5
Leave the old policy in force until approval. Cancel only after the new coverage is issued.

Outside those states you’ll usually answer Medigap underwriting questions to switch. Compare records with Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement rate increase history, Aetna’s rate history and Anthem’s rate history.

Ask a licensed agent to check your rate notice

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Keep Reading

UnitedHealthcare Medicare Supplement Rate Increase History: filed changes from five regulators, requests versus what took effect, and how the shrinking enrollment discount raises premiums.

Physicians Mutual Rate Increases — Frequently Asked Questions

➤ How much has Physicians Mutual raised Medicare Supplement rates in recent years?

In Iowa, its post-2010 plans rose 9% in April 2023, 12% in 2024, 15% in 2025 and 15% in 2026, according to the Iowa Insurance Division. Older pre-2010 forms rose less, from 0% to 9.5% a year.

➤ Is Physicians Life the same as Physicians Mutual?

They are separate insurers in the same Omaha-based group. Physicians Life files its own rates. In Iowa, its modernized Medigap forms rose 22.9% in July 2026.

➤ Did Physicians Mutual ever skip a rate increase?

Yes. In a filing for April 2014, posted by the D.C. insurance regulator, the company proposed no increase for Plans A, B, C, F and J, saying its experience did not require one. It proposed about 6% for Plan G.

➤ Why is Physicians Mutual missing from Rhode Island rate records?

Physicians Mutual does not appear in Rhode Island’s list of Medigap rate requests. Iowa’s report is the most complete public record we found.

➤ What did Physicians Select increase in 2025?

Published filing summaries citing CSG Actuarial data show Plan G changes such as 11% and then 17% in Texas, 9.9% and then 25% in Tennessee, and 9% in Pennsylvania. Iowa lists 14% and 22.7% for Physicians Select in 2025.

➤ Is there a published Physicians Mutual rate increase for 2027?

Not that we could find as of late October 2026. Iowa changes for Physicians Mutual take effect each April, so 2027 figures may appear in spring.

➤ What AM Best rating does Physicians Mutual have?

A+ (Superior). AM Best upgraded Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and Physicians Life Insurance Company from A (Excellent) in November 2025, with a stable outlook.

➤ Should I leave Physicians Mutual after a big increase?

Not automatically. Compare the same plan letter with other companies, check whether your state has a birthday rule, and see if an issue-age option is available. Keep your policy until a replacement is approved.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll