Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Cigna Medicare Supplement Rate Increase History: Filings Before and After the HealthSpring Sale

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 27, 2026

Key Takeaway

Cigna’s Medicare Supplement rate increase history, pieced together from state records, runs from 3.15% to 14.3% a year: Connecticut approved 3.15% on Plan G in 2017 and 12.0% in 2019, and Tennessee’s 2023–24 report lists 13.0% for Cigna National Health and 14.3% for American Retirement Life. Since March 2025 these policies belong to Health Care Service Corporation and now carry the HealthSpring name, so 2027 changes will come from HealthSpring-era filings.

2027 by the Numbers

13.0%

Cigna National Health rate impact, Tennessee SERFF report 2023–24 (UTAC-133975643)

12.0%

Plan G increase approved for Cigna Health and Life, Connecticut order LH 19-61 (Aug. 2019)

$3.3B

HCSC’s price for Cigna’s Medicare businesses; sale closed March 19, 2025 (Cigna release)

6.1%

Average yearly HealthSpring Medigap premium rise over three years in NerdWallet’s tracked markets

Searching for a Cigna Medigap rate history gets harder every month, because the Cigna name is disappearing from the policies. Cigna sold its Medicare business, including the supplemental benefits unit that issues Medicare Supplement (Medigap) coverage, to Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC) in 2025. HCSC finished moving those plans to the HealthSpring brand in September 2026.

Rate history does not reset when a policy changes owners. Below we pulled Connecticut Insurance Department orders and hearing notices, plus Tennessee’s state rate change report, to show what the Cigna companies asked for, what regulators allowed, and what that pattern suggests for renewals under HCSC.

Compare HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) with other Medicare Supplement companies

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

From Cigna to HealthSpring in Four Steps

Timeline of Cigna Medicare Supplement ownership from the 2012 Great American purchase to the 2025 sale to HCSC and the 2026 HealthSpring rebrand

Cigna entered the individual Medigap market by acquisition. In 2012 it bought Great American Supplemental Benefits Group from American Financial Group for about $305 million, and that business was renamed Cigna Supplemental Benefits. Cigna’s next annual report said the deal let it offer individual Medicare Supplement plans.

On January 31, 2024, Cigna agreed to sell its Medicare Advantage, Part D, CareAllies and Cigna Supplemental Benefits businesses to HCSC for $3.3 billion. The sale closed on March 19, 2025. HCSC, which runs Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans in several states, says it is now the second-largest Medigap carrier by policyholders, selling in 48 states and D.C.

The final step came on September 14, 2026, when HCSC announced it had finished rebranding the acquired Medigap and supplemental health products as HealthSpring.

The Legal Companies Behind a Cigna Medigap Policy

State regulators review rates for each insurance company, not each brand. That is why the issuer printed on your policy matters more than the logo. HealthSpring’s 2026 materials name these issuers:

✔
HealthSpring National Health Insurance Company, the former Cigna National Health Insurance Company (same NAIC number, 61727; Missouri’s insurer record now lists a Chicago address, HCSC’s home city).
✔
Loyal American Life Insurance Company (NAIC 65722), a long-time Cigna Medigap issuer.
✔
American Retirement Life Insurance Company (NAIC 88366).
✔
HealthSpring Insurance Company and Medco Containment Life Insurance Company.

Connecticut’s 2026 hearing list also still shows a filing from Cigna Health & Life Insurance Company (Docket LH 26-61, heard July 14, 2026), so some older policies may still sit in a Cigna-named company. Two neighbors with “Cigna” Plan G can be in different blocks with different increases.

Filed Rate Changes for the Cigna Companies, 2017 to 2026

No single public source lists these filings together. The rows below come from Connecticut orders and notices and Tennessee’s SERFF State Rate Change Report. “Approved” means a final order; “requested” means we did not find the decision.

State / company Year Plans Change Source
CT, Cigna Health and Life 2017 A and F / HDF, G and N 5.15% / 3.15% approved Order, Docket LH 17-76 (Aug. 4, 2017)
CT, Cigna Health and Life 2019 A, F and G / N / HDF 12.0% / 8.0% / 0% approved Order, Docket LH 19-61 (Aug. 7, 2019)
CT, Loyal American 2020 A and G approved; F and N denied 8.0% requested on all four Order, Docket LH 20-50 (May 7, 2020)
CT, Cigna Health and Life 2020 A and F / G / N / HDF 13.0% / 7.1% / 6.5% / 0% requested Hearing notice, Docket LH 20-64
TN, Cigna National Health 2023–24 Medigap block, 4,684 policies 13.0% rate impact SERFF UTAC-133975643
TN, American Retirement Life 2023–24 Two blocks, 2,618 and 5,320 policies 14.3% and 7.9% SERFF UTAC-133949950, CSGA-133799949
TN, Loyal American 2023–24 Medigap block, 1,668 policies 8.48% rate impact SERFF UTAC-133728903
CT, Loyal American 2024 A, F, G and N 7.0% requested Hearing notice, Docket LH 24-17
CT, three issuers 2026 Medicare Supplement Increase hearings held Dockets LH 26-08, 26-17, 26-61

For how these figures compare with the wider market, see our overview of Medicare Supplement rate increases.

Check Plan G prices from several insurers in your ZIP code

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

What Connecticut's Orders Show About Approval

Bar chart of Cigna Medicare Supplement rate changes filed in Connecticut and Tennessee from 2017 to 2024, from 3.15% to 14.3%

Connecticut is one of the few states that publishes the full decision, including loss ratios, which is the share of premium paid out in claims. Its August 2019 order approved every Cigna Health and Life request as filed. Nationwide, that block had paid 87.0% of premium in claims since inception, and Plan A had paid 191.5%.

The May 2020 order on Loyal American went the other way for two plans. The company asked for 8.0% on Plans A, F, G and N. The commissioner approved A and G but denied F and N, because the Connecticut block’s lifetime loss ratio had not yet reached the state’s 65% minimum. Nationwide, that company covered 53,168 Medigap policyholders at the end of 2019.

Requested, not decided: We could not locate final orders for the 2020 Cigna Health and Life request, the 2024 Loyal American request or the three 2026 Connecticut hearings. Treat those percentages as asks.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

Tennessee's Report: One Brand, Four Different Increases

Tennessee’s SERFF State Rate Change Report for June 26, 2023 to June 26, 2024 lists each disposed Medigap filing with its rate impact and policy count. Four Cigna-family filings appear, and they are far apart: 13.0% for Cigna National Health, 14.3% and 7.9% for two American Retirement Life blocks, and 8.48% for Loyal American.

The spread is the point. Each company carries its own claims experience, so a renewal can differ by six points in the same state in the same year, under the same brand name.

Worked Example: Three Increases on One Plan G Bill

Take an illustrative $150.00 monthly Plan G premium (not an actual Cigna rate) and apply Connecticut’s Cigna Health and Life Plan G changes in order:

Step by step

✔2017: +3.15% takes $150.00 to $154.73
✔2019: +12.0% takes it to $173.29
✔2020: if the 7.1% request were approved in full, $185.60

What it adds up to

✔Three increases total 23.7%, not 22.25%
✔Each new percentage applies to an already higher base
✔A 13% step on $185.60 would add $24.13 a month

Market-wide pace

✔NerdWallet’s 6.1% a year average, kept up five years, compounds to about 34.5%
✔Birthday-based age increases come on top where pricing is attained-age

The dollar gap widens over time. That is why the trend matters more than any one year’s figure; our guide to Medicare Supplement plans cost explains how each pricing method shapes long-run premiums.

Reading the 2027 Outlook Under HCSC

What the HCSC purchase changed for Cigna Medicare Supplement policyholders and what it left the same

Nothing in the HCSC release says premiums or policy terms will change because of the sale, and Medigap benefits are set by federal standards. What can change is who builds the rate requests: HealthSpring filings now come from HCSC actuaries, using the same blocks of business and claims history Cigna left behind.

Third-party data points to moderate increases rather than spikes. NerdWallet’s 2026 review found HealthSpring Medigap premiums rose an average of 6.1% a year over three years across the markets it tracks, the second-lowest of the companies it reviewed, and its 2026 household discount averaged about 15%. Older closed blocks, though, tend to rise faster as their members age.

Same plan, new letterhead: A renewal letter on HealthSpring paper is still a state-reviewed increase on the same policy. The issuing company and form number on the notice tell you which filing applies.

Before You Renew or Shop Around

✔
Find your issuer. Match the company on your policy to the table above; a filing for one Cigna-family company does not apply to another.
✔
Measure against peers. Plan G is identical everywhere, so compare trends with Aetna, Mutual of Omaha, Physicians Mutual, Anthem and UnitedHealthcare.
✔
Price Plan N too. Our Medicare Supplement Plan N guide covers the copays that come with a lower premium.
✔
Expect health questions when you switch. Outside your open enrollment or a guaranteed issue right, most states let insurers use Medigap underwriting questions.
✔
Keep the household discount in view. Losing it can cost more than a filed increase; see the Medicare Supplement household discount guide.

Ask a licensed agent to review your HealthSpring renewal notice

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Keep Reading

United American Medicare Supplement Rate Increase History: Globe Life’s Medigap company, from Connecticut’s denials and cuts to the 2026 Plan N jumps of up to 20%.

Cigna and HealthSpring Medigap Rate Questions

➤ Who owns Cigna Medicare Supplement plans now?

Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC). Cigna’s sale of its Medicare businesses, including Cigna Supplemental Benefits, closed on March 19, 2025, and HCSC finished rebranding the Medigap plans as HealthSpring in September 2026.

➤ Did the HCSC sale raise my Medigap premium by itself?

Not directly. A change of owner does not alter the plan’s benefits, and any rate change still has to be filed with your state. Your next increase depends on how your block’s claims are running.

➤ How much has Cigna raised Plan G in Connecticut?

Connecticut approved 3.15% for Cigna Health and Life’s Plan G in 2017 and 12.0% in 2019. A 7.1% Plan G increase was requested in 2020; we did not find the final order.

➤ Why did my neighbor’s Cigna plan go up by a different amount?

You may be insured by different companies. In Tennessee’s 2023–24 report, Cigna-family filings ranged from 7.9% to 14.3%, depending on the issuer and block.

➤ Can a state turn down a Cigna Medigap increase?

Yes. In May 2020 Connecticut denied Loyal American’s 8.0% request on Plans F and N because that block’s lifetime loss ratio was still under the state’s 65% minimum, while approving Plans A and G.

➤ Does Cigna Health and Life still file Medigap rates?

At least in Connecticut, yes. The state held a hearing on a Cigna Health & Life Insurance Company Medicare Supplement request on July 14, 2026 (Docket LH 26-61).

➤ What will HealthSpring Medigap rates do in 2027?

No 2027 figures were public when this page was written. NerdWallet’s data shows about 6.1% a year over the last three years, but your notice will state your own change.

➤ Where can I look up the filing behind my increase?

Most states make Medigap rate filings searchable through SERFF Filing Access or the insurance department’s website. Connecticut posts hearing notices and orders, and Tennessee publishes a yearly SERFF rate change report.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll