Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 27, 2026
Key Takeaway
Cigna’s Medicare Supplement rate increase history, pieced together from state records, runs from 3.15% to 14.3% a year: Connecticut approved 3.15% on Plan G in 2017 and 12.0% in 2019, and Tennessee’s 2023–24 report lists 13.0% for Cigna National Health and 14.3% for American Retirement Life. Since March 2025 these policies belong to Health Care Service Corporation and now carry the HealthSpring name, so 2027 changes will come from HealthSpring-era filings.
2027 by the Numbers
13.0%
Cigna National Health rate impact, Tennessee SERFF report 2023–24 (UTAC-133975643)
12.0%
Plan G increase approved for Cigna Health and Life, Connecticut order LH 19-61 (Aug. 2019)
$3.3B
HCSC’s price for Cigna’s Medicare businesses; sale closed March 19, 2025 (Cigna release)
6.1%
Average yearly HealthSpring Medigap premium rise over three years in NerdWallet’s tracked markets
Searching for a Cigna Medigap rate history gets harder every month, because the Cigna name is disappearing from the policies. Cigna sold its Medicare business, including the supplemental benefits unit that issues Medicare Supplement (Medigap) coverage, to Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC) in 2025. HCSC finished moving those plans to the HealthSpring brand in September 2026.
Rate history does not reset when a policy changes owners. Below we pulled Connecticut Insurance Department orders and hearing notices, plus Tennessee’s state rate change report, to show what the Cigna companies asked for, what regulators allowed, and what that pattern suggests for renewals under HCSC.


