Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement 2027: Filed Rates, Discounts, Extras and Who It Suits

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 27, 2026

Key Takeaway

Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement plans are Medigap policies from an Omaha, Nebraska insurance group founded in 1902, issued by Physicians Mutual, Physicians Life or Physicians Select depending on your state, and rated A+ (Superior) by AM Best since November 2025. Its standouts are a cheaper Plan G with a Deductible Discount Rider and a 10% household discount.

2027 by the Numbers

A+ (Superior)

AM Best rating since Nov. 13, 2025, up from A (Excellent) (AM Best)

$224.63

Plan G per month, woman 65, Illinois ZIPs 610 to 617 (Physicians Mutual outline of coverage, rev. 08/2026)

36%

Lower premium for Plan G with the Deductible Discount Rider in that same filing (our math)

About 175,000

Physicians Mutual Medigap members, roughly 1.1% of the market (NerdWallet, 2026)

Physicians Mutual is the company behind those daytime TV ads and mailers offering a free Medicare Supplement information kit. It’s an old Omaha insurer with a strong balance sheet, and it builds a few extras into its Medigap policies that most competitors skip.

This review works from the company’s own paperwork, chiefly its Illinois outline of coverage revised in August 2026, to show what Physicians Mutual actually charges, which discounts and fees change the bill, what’s included and what’s sold on the side.

Compare Physicians Mutual with other Medicare Supplement companies

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Physicians Mutual at a Glance: An Omaha Mutual Since 1902

Edwin E. Elliott founded Physicians Mutual Insurance Company in Omaha in 1902 to sell health coverage to doctors and other medical professionals. It opened its policies to the public in 1962, added Physicians Life Insurance Company in 1970 and, per company material, Physicians Select Insurance Company in 2022.

There are no stock shareholders. AM Best reports the group recently reorganized under Physicians Mutual Holding Company, a mutual holding company that eases access to capital. On November 13, 2025, AM Best raised Physicians Mutual Insurance Company and Physicians Life to A+ (Superior) from A (Excellent), stable outlook. Several reviews still show the old grade.

Medigap is the group’s key line, with about 175,000 members per NerdWallet, mostly in the Midwest, central states and Southeast. It also sells life, dental, cancer and pet coverage.

What the Illinois Outline of Coverage Shows

Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement monthly premiums for a 65-year-old woman in Illinois ZIP codes 610 to 617: Plan G $224.63, Plan N $208.21, Plan A $196.15, Plan G with Deductible Discount Rider $143.40 and High-Deductible Plan G $60.07

Physicians Mutual’s Illinois outline of coverage (form C071-IL, revised 08/2026) lists Plans A, F, G, High-Deductible G and N, plus Plan G with an optional Deductible Discount Rider. Plan F is only for people eligible for Medicare before 2020.

Here are its monthly rates for a woman in Area D, ZIP codes 61000 to 61799, which takes in Rockford and Peoria. Rates are non-tobacco and assume automatic bank withdrawal:

Plan Age 65 Age 70 Rise, 65 to 70 Your share before the plan pays
Plan G $224.63 $257.89 14.8% Part B deductible only
Plan N $208.21 $239.05 14.8% Part B deductible, plus small copays
Plan A $196.15 $225.21 14.8% Part A and Part B deductibles
Plan G + Deductible Discount Rider $143.40 $164.62 14.8% High-deductible amount until the elimination date
High-Deductible Plan G $60.07 $72.38 20.5% $2,950 in 2026, $3,050 in 2027

The filing is attained age, so every row climbs with each birthday, before any general increase. Plan A runs only about $28 a month below Plan G while covering far less. To see what the full plan covers, read our guide to Medicare Supplement Plan G.

Price Plan G with and without the Deductible Discount Rider

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Plan G With the Deductible Discount Rider, Worked Out

Physicians Mutual markets this as Innovative Plan G. It works like High-Deductible Plan G until the Deductible Elimination Date on your policy schedule, up to three calendar years per company material. Then the deductible drops to zero and the lower premium stays.

Worked example: the 65-year-old woman in the table pays $224.63 a month for regular Plan G or $143.40 with the rider, a gap of $81.23 a month, or $974.76 a year. With 2026 figures, a bad year costs her up to $2,950 under the rider instead of the $283 Part B deductible, a worst-case net loss of about $1,692. After the deductible ends, the roughly $975 yearly saving carries no extra risk.

Before choosing it: The company says more than 8 in 10 rider customers never reach the deductible. That is its own figure. Anyone facing planned surgery may fare better on regular Plan G.

For a different insurer’s filed Plan G numbers, see our Aetna Medicare Supplement Plan G breakdown.

Discounts, Fees and How the Bill Is Calculated

Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement discounts and fees: 10% household discount, 10% non-tobacco rates and a $5 monthly fee avoided by paying through automatic bank withdrawal

The outline spells out adjustments most quote tools blur together:

✔
Household discount: 10% off if you live with your spouse, or with up to three other people age 60 or older who have lived with you for the past 12 months. It can be added later by questionnaire.
✔
Non-tobacco rates: the published rates already include a 10% non-tobacco discount. Tobacco users divide the listed rate by 0.9, so a $224.63 rate becomes about $249.59.
✔
Payment method: the rates assume automatic bank withdrawal. A monthly paper bill or monthly credit card adds $5 a month, and the household discount is taken before that fee.

Compare rules across carriers in our Medicare Supplement household discount guide.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

Extras Inside the Policy: Preventive Care and a Second Chance

In Illinois, every Physicians Mutual plan except Plan A is a “Wellness Plus” policy. It pays for preventive care your doctor deems appropriate when Medicare doesn’t, excluding dental, vision, hearing tests, chiropractic care and drugs. In some states this is a paid rider instead, per NerdWallet. See also do Medicare Supplement plans cover annual physicals.

The second-chance guarantee lets a first-time customer switch to a different Physicians Mutual Medigap policy once within the first two years, with no health questions. That’s different from the federal 30-day Medicare Supplement free look period, and useful if you start on the rider and later want regular Plan G.

Dental, Vision and Hearing: Sold Separately

What a Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement policy includes compared with the dental plan and Vision and Hearing Rider the company sells separately

No Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement policy covers routine dental work, glasses or hearing aids. Those come from its separate dental insurance, which can carry a Vision and Hearing Rider listed at $8.95 a month for an individual.

Vision

✔Eye exam: up to $100 per person each year, no wait
✔Glasses or contacts: up to $150 after a 3-month wait
✔VSP discounts, including up to 20% off laser surgery

Hearing

✔Hearing exam: up to $75 per person each year
✔Hearing aids: up to $500 per ear after a 12-month wait
✔One aid per ear every 5 years

A $500 per-ear benefit covers only part of most hearing aids. See whether Medicare Plan G covers hearing aids.

Where Physicians Mutual Sells, and How You Buy

State counts disagree. NerdWallet says 26 states plus D.C.; ValuePenguin lists 30 plus D.C., including California, yet Physicians Mutual’s own Medigap pages say it isn’t sold in California. An agent-contracting list names 24 states, from Alabama and Arizona to Texas, Utah and Wisconsin, which uses its own plan design.

It sells two ways: directly through TV, mail, phone and online applications, and through independent agents contracted via marketing organizations. Filed rates generally don’t change by channel, and an independent agent can price rivals on the same call.

Name on the policy: Depending on your state, the issuer may be Physicians Mutual Insurance Company, Physicians Life Insurance Company or Physicians Select Insurance Company.

Ask an independent agent about Physicians Mutual

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Complaints, Rate History and Who Physicians Mutual Suits

Service reviews are mixed. NerdWallet’s analysis of 2023 to 2025 NAIC data found Physicians Mutual Medigap members filed complaints about 50% more often than average, while ValuePenguin rated its Medigap customer service as good.

On pricing, Iowa’s records show its post-2010 plans rising each April since 2023, up 15% in 2026, and NerdWallet puts the three-year average at 6.4% a year. The full record is in our Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement rate increase history, and how filings work is covered in Medicare Supplement rate increases.

✔
Likely fits: healthy shoppers who want Plan G’s coverage at a lower premium and can absorb a high deductible for a few years.
✔
Likely fits: people sharing a home with a spouse or someone 60 or older, who get 10% off.
✔
Look elsewhere: if a rival’s regular Plan G is clearly cheaper in your ZIP code, since NerdWallet found Physicians Mutual’s standard Plan G about 21% above the lowest price it checked.

See how it ranks against other carriers in our list of the best Medicare Supplement companies.

Keep Reading

United American Medicare Supplement 2027: Globe Life’s Medigap insurer, its ten-letter plan menu and how its filed Maine rates stack up against 13 other companies.

Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement: Shopper Questions

➤ Is Physicians Mutual owned by its policyholders?

It’s a mutual insurer with no stock shareholders, and AM Best says it recently reorganized under Physicians Mutual Holding Company, a mutual holding company structure.

➤ Can I buy a Physicians Mutual Medigap plan in California?

Physicians Mutual’s own Medicare Supplement pages say the product isn’t available in California, even though some third-party reviews list it there.

➤ What does the Deductible Discount Rider do?

Plan G runs like High-Deductible Plan G until the elimination date on your policy schedule, then the deductible ends. In Illinois it cut the age-65 rate about 36%.

➤ Who counts toward the Physicians Mutual household discount?

A spouse you live with, or up to three other people age 60 or older who have lived with you for the past 12 months. The discount is 10% in the Illinois filing.

➤ Does Physicians Mutual charge a fee to mail me a bill?

The Illinois outline adds $5 a month for a paper bill or monthly card payment. Bank withdrawal avoids it.

➤ Will my Physicians Mutual Medigap policy pay for glasses or hearing aids?

No. A separate dental plan with a Vision and Hearing Rider pays up to $150 for glasses and $500 per ear for hearing aids, after waiting periods.

➤ Can I change plans after I enroll with Physicians Mutual?

First-time customers get one switch to a different Physicians Mutual Medigap policy within two years, with no health questions, under the company’s second-chance guarantee.

➤ Do I have to buy Physicians Mutual directly from the company?

No. Independent agents appointed with Physicians Mutual can enroll you and also quote other insurers.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll