Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

United American Medicare Supplement 2027: Company Review, Plan Menu and a State Rate Sheet Test

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 5, 2026

Key Takeaway

United American Medicare Supplement plans come from United American Insurance Company, a Globe Life subsidiary founded in 1947 that has sold Medigap coverage since 1966 and is rated A (Excellent) by AM Best. It stands out for selling more plan letters than most insurers, including K, L, D and B, through independent agents in 47 states and D.C.

2027 by the Numbers

$2,999

United American Plan G, yearly, lowest Plan G of 14 insurers on Maine’s state rate guide (Maine Bureau of Insurance)

10

Plan columns with a United American rate in that guide, tied with Humana for most (Maine Bureau of Insurance)

AA-

S&P Global financial strength rating, as of Oct. 2025 (United American)

47 + D.C.

States where it sells; not Massachusetts, Minnesota or New York (NerdWallet, Aug. 2026)

United American is one of the oldest names in Medicare Supplement insurance, yet it spends little on consumer advertising, so plenty of buyers meet it for the first time on an agent’s quote sheet. National reviews call it pricey; a state rate sheet tells a more mixed story.

This review covers who owns the company, which plan letters it sells, how it reaches buyers, its ratings and underwriting, and its group retiree business. It also tests the pricing claim against the annual rate table the Maine Bureau of Insurance posts for every Medigap insurer in that state.

Compare United American with other Medicare Supplement insurers

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

From a 1947 Dallas Startup to a Globe Life Subsidiary

United American Insurance Company timeline: founded 1947, Dallas 1955, first Medicare Supplement program 1966, Torchmark purchase 1982, McKinney 1996 and Globe Life name 2019

C.L. Dunlap founded United American Insurance Company in 1947. Company history pages say it moved to downtown Dallas in 1955, launched its first Medicare Supplement program in 1966, the year Medicare began, and was bought by Torchmark Corporation in 1982. Headquarters moved north to McKinney, Texas, in 1996.

Torchmark renamed itself Globe Life Inc. in 2019, so United American is now a wholly owned Globe Life subsidiary. NerdWallet puts the parent’s Medigap enrollment near 224,000 people, about 1.3% of the national market.

Ten Plan Letters on One State Rate Sheet

Maine Bureau of Insurance yearly Plan G premiums: United American $2,999, State Farm $3,299, Medco $3,322, Plateau $3,676, Washington National $3,826 and Humana $5,554

Maine’s Bureau of Insurance publishes a yearly rate table for every Medigap company selling there. Most list four or five letters; United American fills 10 of the 12 plan columns, tied with Humana for the most. Here are its posted yearly premiums, with monthly amounts we divided out:

Plan United American, per year Per month (our math) Lowest rival in Maine’s table, per year
Plan G $2,999 $249.92 None lower (State Farm $3,299 next)
Plan N $3,324 $277.00 Medco $2,451 non-smoker
Plan K $1,547 $128.92 UnitedHealthcare $1,407 non-smoker
Plan L $2,286 $190.50 None lower (UnitedHealthcare $2,544 next)
High-Deductible G $746 $62.17 Tied with United of Omaha $746
Plan A $2,079 $173.25 None lower (State Farm $2,641 next)
Plans B / D $2,508 / $2,716 $209.00 / $226.33 Few or no rivals list them
Plan F / HD-F $3,282 / $746 $273.50 / $62.17 Before-2020 eligibility only

Source: Maine Bureau of Insurance, Medicare Supplement Annual Rates, as posted in November 2026 under a 2026 high-deductible amount of $2,950. The table shows one figure per plan and no age. NerdWallet’s national review says United American sells A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L and N, never M, with Wisconsin plans built to that state’s own design.

Get a Plan G, Plan N or Plan K quote for your ZIP code

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

What the Maine Figures Show That National Reviews Miss

NerdWallet priced United American’s Plan G about 74% above the cheapest company it checked in Los Angeles, Atlanta and Dallas. Maine’s table points the other way for that one letter: $2,999 a year is the lowest Plan G among 14 companies, $300 under State Farm and $2,555 under Humana’s non-smoker rate.

✔
Plan N costs more than Plan G here. At $3,324, United American’s Plan N runs $325 a year above its own Plan G, so N’s usual trade of copays for savings disappears. Compare the two in our Medicare Supplement Plan N guide.
✔
No smoker surcharge is shown. Most rivals list a separate, higher smoker rate. United American posts one figure, which widens its edge for tobacco users.
✔
Cost-sharing letters are cheap. Plan K at $1,547 and High-Deductible G at $746 suit buyers who would rather carry risk than pay a high premium. See High-Deductible Plan G, whose deductible reaches $3,050 in 2027.

One state, one snapshot: Pricing is set state by state. Maine’s numbers do not predict a quote in Texas or Ohio, and the table may trail mid-year rate changes.

How United American Sells: Agents, Not Websites

Individual policies are sold through independent agents and agencies, per the company’s own description, and NerdWallet lists the lack of online quotes as a drawback.

United American runs no provider network, so any doctor who accepts Medicare works. Its FAQ says most claims arrive straight from Medicare and the provider, and policyholders can follow a claim through an online tracker. NerdWallet found no household or spousal discount and no bundled extras, a contrast with carriers covered in our Medicare Supplement household discount guide.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

Financial Strength, Complaints and Claims Payout

Credit ratings

✔AM Best: A (Excellent), as of Nov. 2025
✔S&P Global: AA- (Very Strong), Oct. 2025
✔Fitch: A+ (Strong), Sept. 2025

Service record

✔Complaints about 14% above average, NAIC 2023 to 2025, per NerdWallet
✔BBB-accredited since 1952, A+ grade

Benefits paid

✔About 78% of premium paid as benefits, 2024 NAIC data
✔All-company average: 84.5%

Three agencies rate the insurer’s claims-paying ability strongly, so solvency is not the concern. The weaker marks come from service complaints and a payout ratio below the market average. The pricing record behind those figures, from Connecticut orders to 2026 filings, sits on our United American Medicare Supplement rate increase history page; in short, Plan N took the sharpest 2026 increases in several states.

Underwriting, Waiting Periods and Timing Your Application

Federal rules bar United American, like any Medigap insurer, from denying you or charging more for health reasons during your six-month Medicare Supplement open enrollment window or when a guaranteed issue right applies. Outside those windows it may ask health questions and decline the application.

1
Check your window. Know whether open enrollment or a guaranteed issue right covers you; our open enrollment vs guaranteed issue guide sorts the two.
2
Ask about the pre-existing wait. Maine’s table lists a 60-day pre-existing exclusion period for United American, shorter than the 3 or 6 months shown for several rivals. Prior creditable coverage can shorten or erase it; see Medicare Supplement pre-existing conditions.
3
Prepare for the health section. Typical questions are listed in Medigap underwriting questions.
4
Use the free look. A 30-day Medicare Supplement free look period applies when replacing a policy, so keep the old one until the new one is issued.

Group Retiree Plans: The Side of the Business Few Reviews Cover

Beyond individual policies, United American sells Group Retiree Health plans to employers and unions that want to supplement Medicare for retired workers, spouses and surviving spouses. The company says it has built group products since the 1990s and serves hundreds of retiree groups, some for 30 years.

Group designs can carry custom deductibles, coinsurance, out-of-pocket caps and copay riders, and the company advertises guaranteed acceptance for eligible retirees. If a former employer offers one, compare its contribution and benefits with an individual plan before declining it.

Ask a licensed agent which United American plan letters your state allows

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Strengths, Drawbacks and Who United American Fits

United American Medicare Supplement strengths and drawbacks: wide plan menu, strong ratings and group retiree plans vs no online quotes, no discounts found and above-average complaints

United American tends to suit shoppers who want a less common letter such as K, L, B or D, who live where its Plan G is filed competitively, or who use tobacco in a state where it posts a single rate. It fits less well for anyone who wants online shopping, a household discount or extras like gym or vision perks.

Fair comparison: Plan benefits are fixed by federal law for each letter, so a United American Medicare Supplement Plan G pays the same claims as any other Plan G. Price, rate trend and service are what differ.

For other carrier reviews in this series, start with Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement, then compare the field in our ranking of the best Medicare Supplement companies.

Keep Reading

Philadelphia American Medicare Supplement 2027: New Era’s Houston insurer, its A- rating with a negative outlook, a rare Plan M filing and New Jersey’s cheapest High-Deductible G.

United American Medicare Supplement: Questions Buyers Ask

➤ Who owns United American Insurance Company?

Globe Life Inc. of McKinney, Texas. Torchmark Corporation bought United American in 1982 and changed its own name to Globe Life in 2019.

➤ Which Medigap letters can I buy from United American?

NerdWallet lists A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L and N plus high-deductible G and F in certain areas, but not Plan M. C and F are limited to people eligible for Medicare before 2020.

➤ Is United American Plan G really more expensive than other companies?

It depends on the state. NerdWallet found it well above the cheapest option in three cities, while Maine’s 2026 rate guide shows United American with the lowest Plan G of 14 insurers.

➤ Why does United American Plan N cost more than Plan G in Maine?

Each letter is priced on its own claims experience. Maine’s guide lists Plan N at $3,324 a year against $2,999 for Plan G, so Plan G is the better buy there.

➤ Can I get a United American quote online?

NerdWallet reports no online quotes. Quotes come through independent agents or by phone.

➤ Does United American have a provider network?

No. Its FAQ says there is no network, so any provider who accepts Medicare can be used.

➤ Does United American offer plans through employers?

Yes. Its Group Retiree Health plans supplement Medicare for retirees and spouses of qualifying employer and union groups.

➤ What ratings does United American hold?

AM Best A (Excellent), S&P Global AA- (Very Strong) and Fitch A+ (Strong), as listed by the company in late 2025.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll