Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 5, 2026
Key Takeaway
United American Medicare Supplement plans come from United American Insurance Company, a Globe Life subsidiary founded in 1947 that has sold Medigap coverage since 1966 and is rated A (Excellent) by AM Best. It stands out for selling more plan letters than most insurers, including K, L, D and B, through independent agents in 47 states and D.C.
2027 by the Numbers
$2,999
United American Plan G, yearly, lowest Plan G of 14 insurers on Maine’s state rate guide (Maine Bureau of Insurance)
10
Plan columns with a United American rate in that guide, tied with Humana for most (Maine Bureau of Insurance)
AA-
S&P Global financial strength rating, as of Oct. 2025 (United American)
47 + D.C.
States where it sells; not Massachusetts, Minnesota or New York (NerdWallet, Aug. 2026)
United American is one of the oldest names in Medicare Supplement insurance, yet it spends little on consumer advertising, so plenty of buyers meet it for the first time on an agent’s quote sheet. National reviews call it pricey; a state rate sheet tells a more mixed story.
This review covers who owns the company, which plan letters it sells, how it reaches buyers, its ratings and underwriting, and its group retiree business. It also tests the pricing claim against the annual rate table the Maine Bureau of Insurance posts for every Medigap insurer in that state.


