Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 27, 2026
Key Takeaway
Physicians Mutual Medicare Supplement plans are Medigap policies from an Omaha, Nebraska insurance group founded in 1902, issued by Physicians Mutual, Physicians Life or Physicians Select depending on your state, and rated A+ (Superior) by AM Best since November 2025. Its standouts are a cheaper Plan G with a Deductible Discount Rider and a 10% household discount.
2027 by the Numbers
A+ (Superior)
AM Best rating since Nov. 13, 2025, up from A (Excellent) (AM Best)
$224.63
Plan G per month, woman 65, Illinois ZIPs 610 to 617 (Physicians Mutual outline of coverage, rev. 08/2026)
36%
Lower premium for Plan G with the Deductible Discount Rider in that same filing (our math)
About 175,000
Physicians Mutual Medigap members, roughly 1.1% of the market (NerdWallet, 2026)
Physicians Mutual is the company behind those daytime TV ads and mailers offering a free Medicare Supplement information kit. It’s an old Omaha insurer with a strong balance sheet, and it builds a few extras into its Medigap policies that most competitors skip.
This review works from the company’s own paperwork, chiefly its Illinois outline of coverage revised in August 2026, to show what Physicians Mutual actually charges, which discounts and fees change the bill, what’s included and what’s sold on the side.


