Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Allstate Medicare Supplement 2027: The Exit From New Sales, Who Issues Policies and What Iowa's Rate Filings Show

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 9, 2026

Key Takeaway

Allstate Medicare Supplement plans are being withdrawn from new sales: in May 2025 Allstate Health Solutions told agents it would exit the Medicare Supplement market state by state, while existing policies stay in force and keep being serviced. Most are issued by National Health Insurance Company, rated A (Excellent) by AM Best, not the A+ many review sites print.

2027 by the Numbers

A

AM Best financial strength for National Health Insurance Company, affirmed Sept. 2, 2026 (AM Best)

24.9%

Rate change on its Iowa Plan A, F, G and N form effective Nov. 1, 2026, the third in a row (Iowa Insurance Division)

~44,000

Allstate Medicare Supplement members affected by the exit, per May 2025 agency notices

$1.25B

Allstate’s group health sale to Nationwide, closed July 1, 2025; Medigap was not part of it (Allstate SEC filings)

Many review pages still describe Allstate Medicare Supplement plans as a growing, low-priced option. That picture is out of date. Allstate entered Medigap through its January 2021 purchase of National General, sold two of its three health businesses in 2025, and that same spring began pulling its Medicare Supplement product from new sales.

This page sorts out what changed using Allstate’s SEC filings, AM Best’s September 2026 rating action and Iowa’s rate-change report, mainly for people who already hold an Allstate policy.

Compare Medicare Supplement companies still taking applications

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Can You Still Buy an Allstate Medicare Supplement Plan?

What the Allstate Medicare Supplement exit means for current policyholders: coverage, benefits and servicing continue, while new sales end and rate increases continue

For most buyers, no. In a notice to agents dated around May 14, 2025, Allstate Health Solutions said it would file with each state to leave the Medicare Supplement market. From that point it accepted only paper applications for new Medigap business, suspended advance commissions to agents, and said it would keep taking applications only until each state’s notice period ran out.

The same notice said the change does not affect existing policyholders and that their coverage and service continue uninterrupted. Agency bulletins put the affected group at roughly 44,000 members nationwide.

Old quotes: A comparison sheet or website that still shows an Allstate Plan G or Plan N price is likely using rates from before the exit. Treat it as a reference point, not an offer you can buy for 2027.

Who Actually Issues an Allstate Medicare Supplement Policy?

Allstate Health Solutions is a marketing name. The insurer whose name appears on the policy is usually National Health Insurance Company (NAIC 82538), a former National General subsidiary whose ultimate parent is now The Allstate Corporation. Agent materials list it as the Medigap underwriter in 44 states and Washington, D.C.

Texas is one known exception: Allstate’s April 2024 Texas brochure names American Heritage Life Insurance Company as the underwriter. American Heritage Life was one of the companies in Allstate’s April 1, 2025 sale of its employer voluntary benefits business to StanCorp Financial Group (The Standard). Texas policyholders should check the company name and phone number on their most recent bill.

Record What it shows Source
Issuing company (most states) National Health Insurance Company Agent materials; AM Best
AM Best rating A (Excellent), stable, affirmed Sept. 2, 2026 AM Best
Plan letters filed A, F, High-Deductible F, G, N Iowa Insurance Division; agent guides
Latest Iowa rate change 24.9%, effective Nov. 1, 2026 Iowa Insurance Division
New sales Withdrawn state by state from May 2025 Allstate Health Solutions notice

Allstate’s separate Allstate hospital indemnity insurance product comes from the same individual health unit, but it is a cash-benefit plan, not a Medigap policy.

Why Review Sites Disagree on Allstate's Rating

Many Medigap reviews credit Allstate with an AM Best rating of A+ (Superior). Those ratings belong to Allstate’s property and casualty companies, such as Allstate Insurance Company and the National General auto insurers, which AM Best rates A+ as part of the Allstate Insurance Group.

National Health Insurance Company is rated separately. AM Best’s September 2, 2026 action affirmed it at A (Excellent) with a long-term issuer credit rating of a+, both with stable outlooks. AM Best notes the rating leans on Allstate’s support, and a drop in the company’s strategic importance to Allstate could pressure it.

What Allstate Sold in 2025, and What It Kept

Allstate Medicare Supplement timeline: National General purchase in January 2021, voluntary benefits sale to StanCorp April 2025, Medicare Supplement exit notice May 2025, group health sale to Nationwide July 2025

Allstate announced in late 2023 that it would sell its health and benefits businesses. Two sales closed in 2025:

✔
Employer voluntary benefits went to StanCorp Financial Group for about $2.0 billion, closing April 1, 2025.
✔
Group health went to Nationwide Life Insurance Company for about $1.25 billion, closing July 1, 2025.
✔
Individual health, which Allstate’s 2024 annual report described as short-term medical, Medicare supplement and ancillary products, was not sold. That report said it would either be retained or divested; Allstate’s mid-2026 investor supplement still counts about 495,000 individual health certificates in force.

So there was no buyer for the Medigap book. Allstate kept the existing policies and chose to stop writing new ones, which is why the company and phone number on your policy should not have changed because of these sales.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

Iowa's Filings: Three Straight 24.9% Rate Changes

Iowa rate changes for National Health Insurance Company's Medicare Supplement form: -4.5% in 2022, 6.0% in 2023, then 24.9% in 2024, 2025 and 2026

Iowa publishes every Medigap insurer’s rate changes by form. Its July 2026 report lists National Health Insurance Company’s 2010-standardized form (Plans A, F, High-Deductible F, G and N) with these changes: a 4.5% decrease in May 2022, 6.0% in August 2023, then 24.9% in September 2024, November 2025 and November 2026. The report doesn’t split every percentage by plan letter, so individual plans may differ.

Here is what three increases of that size do to a hypothetical $150 monthly premium:

1
Start. $150 a month before the September 2024 change.
2
After 2024. $150 times 1.249 is $187.35.
3
After 2025. $187.35 times 1.249 is $234.00.
4
After November 2026. $234.00 times 1.249 is $292.27, nearly double the starting premium, before any age-based increases.

Other states set their own approved amounts, so Iowa is a signal, not a forecast for your state. Our Medicare Supplement rate increases guide explains how insurers file and justify these changes.

Get 2027 quotes for the plan letter you have now

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

If You Already Own an Allstate Policy

A Medigap policy is guaranteed renewable under federal law. Allstate can raise rates for everyone on the same form in your state, but it cannot cancel your policy because it stopped selling new ones, as long as you pay the premium and answered the application truthfully.

✔
Your plan letter’s benefits stay exactly the same; Plan G still covers what every Plan G covers.
✔
Household, annual-pay or other discounts on your policy follow its terms; a new application elsewhere has its own rules, explained in our Medicare Supplement household discount guide.
✔
Fitness and hearing discount extras were never insurance and can change separately.
✔
Keep the customer service number from your policy or ID card; that is still the right number for claims and billing.

Policy check: Find the issuing company’s name on page one of your policy. That name, not the Allstate brand, is what to use when you look up rate filings or contact your state insurance department.

Switching Away: Timing and Underwriting

An insurer leaving the market for new sales is not, by itself, a federal guaranteed issue event. The federal guaranteed issue rights tied to an existing Medigap policy apply if your insurer goes bankrupt, if the policy ends through no fault of yours, or if the insurer misled you. Since Allstate policies remain in force, most switchers will apply with medical underwriting.

1
Check your state first. Some states give yearly switching rights without health questions. See Medicare Supplement guaranteed issue rights by state, including the California birthday rule and the Illinois birthday rule.
2
Review the health questions. Read typical Medigap underwriting questions before applying.
3
Compare the same letter. Quote your current plan, or move from F to G if it saves enough; our switch Plan F to Plan G page shows the math.
4
Overlap, don’t gap. Keep the Allstate policy until the new one is approved, then cancel during the new policy’s Medicare Supplement free look period window if needed.

Comparing Other Medicare Supplement Companies for 2027

Because benefits are standardized, the decision comes down to premium, rate trend, rating and service. Ask any replacement insurer for its last three years of rate changes in your state.

Start with our ranking of the best Medicare Supplement companies, then read individual reviews such as Philadelphia American Medicare Supplement, or State Farm Medicare Supplement, a big brand still selling.

Keep Reading

Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement 2027: the four Omaha insurers behind the policies, plan letters, the 7% or 12% household discount, Mutually Well perks and Missouri complaint records.

Allstate Medicare Supplement: Questions Policyholders Ask

➤ Did Allstate stop selling Medicare Supplement insurance?

Yes, for new buyers. In May 2025 Allstate Health Solutions began withdrawing its Medicare Supplement product state by state and limited new business to paper applications until each state’s notice period ended.

➤ Will my Allstate Medigap policy be cancelled?

No. Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable, and Allstate’s notice said existing coverage and service continue. The policy stays in force as long as you pay the premium.

➤ Was Allstate’s Medicare Supplement business sold to Nationwide or The Standard?

No. Nationwide bought Allstate’s group health business and The Standard bought its employer voluntary benefits business. Individual health, which includes Medigap, was kept by Allstate.

➤ Is National Health Insurance Company the same as Allstate?

It is an Allstate subsidiary that came with the 2021 National General purchase. It issues most Allstate Medicare Supplement policies and is rated A (Excellent) by AM Best.

➤ Why did my Allstate premium go up so much?

Rate increases are filed by state. In Iowa, the company’s Plan A, F, G and N form had 24.9% changes in 2024, 2025 and 2026. Your state’s approved amount may be different.

➤ Do I get guaranteed issue because Allstate left the market?

Not under federal rules, since your policy hasn’t ended. A state birthday or anniversary rule may still let you switch without health questions.

➤ Can I keep my household discount if I stay?

Discounts on an existing policy follow the policy’s own terms. Check your latest renewal notice or call the number on your ID card to confirm what still applies.

➤ Who do I contact about claims on my Allstate Medicare Supplement?

Use the customer service number on your policy or member ID card. Texas policies issued by American Heritage Life should be checked against the name and number on your most recent bill.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll