Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement 2027: Plans, Discounts, Complaint Record and the Companies Behind the Policy

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 10, 2026

Key Takeaway

Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement plans are sold in every state except Massachusetts, plus Washington, D.C., through a family of Omaha-based insurers rated A+ (Superior) by AM Best. Expect Plans G, N and High-Deductible G for 2027, a household discount of 7% or 12% depending on the state, and premiums that often run above the lowest quote in a ZIP code.

2027 by the Numbers

A+

AM Best financial strength for Mutual of Omaha and its Medigap affiliates, affirmed April 2, 2026 (AM Best)

7% or 12%

Household discount, depending on the state (Mutual of Omaha agent materials)

~58

Combined 2023 Missouri Medicare Supplement complaint index for four Mutual of Omaha insurers; 100 = market average (our math from Missouri DCI data)

1.3M+

Medigap members, about 9.3% of the market (NerdWallet 2026 review)

Mutual of Omaha has sold coverage alongside Medicare since the program’s first year. A quote with its logo can come from any of four related insurers, though, and each files its own rates and builds its own complaint record.

This review covers the company, its 2027 plan letters and discounts, the perks, and what Missouri’s complaint files show for each Mutual of Omaha insurer.

Compare Mutual of Omaha with other Medicare Supplement companies

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

From a 1909 Accident Association to a Mutual Holding Company

Mutual of Omaha history: founded 1909, renamed 1950, Wild Kingdom 1963, early Medicare supplement coverage 1966, mutual holding company April 2026

The company began in Omaha, Nebraska, as Mutual Benefit Health & Accident Association, with its articles of incorporation filed in March 1909. It took the name Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company in 1950, sponsored Wild Kingdom from its January 1963 debut, and was among the first insurers to offer coverage that supplemented Medicare when the program started in 1966.

The most recent change came on April 1, 2026. With policyholder approval, Nebraska regulators signed off on a mutual holding company reorganization. Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company is now a stock insurer owned by Mutual of Omaha Holding Company, whose members are the policyholders. Nobody received stock or cash, and Medigap benefits did not change; the move mainly widens the group’s access to capital.

The Four Insurers That Issue Mutual of Omaha Policies

The company named on your policy depends on your state and purchase date. Four Omaha-based insurers report Medicare Supplement business to state regulators:

✔
Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company (NAIC 71412), the original parent insurer.
✔
United of Omaha Life Insurance Company (NAIC 69868), a subsidiary that dates to 1926 under the name United Benefit Life and took its current name in 1981.
✔
United World Life Insurance Company (NAIC 72850); Mutual of Omaha’s own Medicare Supplement page currently names it as the underwriter of its policy forms.
✔
Omaha Insurance Company (NAIC 13100), another affiliate that has written Medigap in some states.

AM Best’s April 2, 2026 action affirmed an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating and an aa- issuer credit rating, both stable, for Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company, United of Omaha, United World Life and Companion Life. Omaha Insurance Company was not named in that release, so if your quote comes from it, ask the agent for that company’s current rating.

Plan Letters Mutual of Omaha Offers for 2027

Mutual of Omaha’s policy materials reference Plans A, B, C, D, F, G, M and N, plus high-deductible versions of F and G. Few states get every letter, and Plans C and F (including High-Deductible F) remain closed to anyone who first became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020.

Core lineup

✔Plan G for broad coverage
✔Plan N for lower premiums with small copays
✔High-Deductible G with a $3,050 deductible in 2027

Sold in some states

✔Plans A, B, D and M
✔Plans C and F for those eligible before 2020
✔Minnesota and Wisconsin get their own state-standard plans

Not sold

✔Massachusetts has no Mutual of Omaha Medigap
✔Some forms aren’t available in every state

Benefits are fixed by plan letter, so a Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement Plan G pays the same claims as any other company’s Plan G. For the trade-offs between letters, see Medicare Supplement Plan N and High-Deductible Plan G.

Get 2027 Medicare Supplement quotes for your ZIP code

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Household Discount and How Premiums Are Priced

Agent materials put Mutual of Omaha’s household discount at 7% or 12%, depending on the state. In many states the other adult can be a spouse, a domestic partner or a roommate, and in some states that person must also hold or apply for a Mutual of Omaha Medigap policy. Our Medicare Supplement household discount guide compares other carriers’ rules.

Most policies use attained-age pricing, so premiums rise with age, and rates differ by ZIP code, sex and tobacco use. The starting price is rarely the lowest: in NerdWallet’s check of Los Angeles, Atlanta and Dallas, Mutual of Omaha’s Plan G averaged about 47% more than the cheapest company it reviewed, before discounts.

Worth knowing: A 12% discount on a $200 monthly premium is $24 a month, or $288 a year. That can close much of the gap with a cheaper carrier, so always compare prices after discounts.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

Rate Increases in Brief

Rate changes are filed state by state, and recent Plan G requests have run high. We track the filings, approved amounts and Plan G requests in a separate page on Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement rate increase history. No 2027 percentages had been published when this review was updated.

Complaint Record: What Missouri's Files Show

Combined Missouri Medicare Supplement complaint index for Mutual of Omaha's four insurers: about 18 in 2021, 43 in 2022 and 58 in 2023, against a market average of 100

Missouri’s Department of Commerce and Insurance publishes a complaint index for each insurer and line of business. It compares a company’s complaints with its share of premiums; 100 means the company matches the market average, and lower is better. We pulled the Medicare Supplement line for all four Mutual of Omaha insurers.

Insurer (2023, Missouri) Medigap market share Complaints Complaint index
Mutual of Omaha Insurance Co. 7.87% 1 17
Omaha Insurance Co. 6.41% 3 62
United of Omaha Life 1.28% 1 103
United World Life 0.29% 2 892
All four combined (our math) 15.85% 7 ~58

Together the four held nearly 16% of Missouri’s Medigap market in 2023 and drew seven complaints, a combined index of about 58, or roughly 40% fewer complaints than their size predicts. The same method gives about 18 for 2021 and 43 for 2022, so the trend is rising. United World’s 892 reflects two complaints on a tiny share.

Missouri caveat: The 2024 listings show 0% market share for all four companies, which looks like incomplete data, so we left 2024 out. Nationally, NerdWallet reports Mutual of Omaha draws 58% fewer complaints than average based on 2023 to 2025 NAIC data.

Ask a licensed agent which Mutual of Omaha company serves your state

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Perks Outside the Policy: Mutually Well, Vision and Hearing

Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement perks: Mutually Well gym access for $29.99 a month, EyeMed $50 eye exam, Amplifon hearing aid discounts, up to 30% off healthy living services

Any Mutual of Omaha Medigap plan unlocks Mutually Well, a discount program run with Tivity Health. Gym access at 10,000+ locations costs $29.99 a month with no contract. It also includes EyeMed vision pricing, such as a $50 eye exam and 40% off frames up to $140, and Amplifon hearing aid discounts with a 60-day trial at over 7,000 locations.

These are discounts, not insurance, and Mutual of Omaha can end them at any time. Mutually Well, EyeMed and Amplifon are not offered in New York. Medigap itself doesn’t pay for hearing aids; see whether Medicare Plan G covers hearing aids.

Applying, and Who Mutual of Omaha Fits

1
Time it. During your six-month Medigap open enrollment, Mutual of Omaha cannot turn you down or charge more for health reasons. See Medicare Supplement open enrollment.
2
Get the issuing company’s name. Ask which of the four insurers your quote comes from, then check that company’s rating and complaint record.
3
Expect health questions later. Outside open enrollment or a birthday rule state window, you’ll answer Medigap underwriting questions.
4
Apply your discount. List a spouse or other qualifying adult on the application.
5
Don’t drop old coverage early. Keep your current plan until Mutual of Omaha approves the new one.

Pros

✔A+ (Superior) AM Best rating
✔Household discount up to 12%, often without a spouse
✔Low complaint index in Missouri and nationally
✔Free perks package with every plan

Cons

✔Premiums often above the lowest quote
✔Plan G increase requests have been large
✔Issuing company varies, and so does its record
✔No Medigap in Massachusetts

It suits buyers who value an established insurer and can use the household discount. If price matters most, see Aetna vs Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement, read our review of Allstate Medicare Supplement, and see the best Medicare Supplement companies. People who also want cash for hospital stays can look at Mutual of Omaha hospital indemnity insurance.

Keep Reading

Manhattan Life Medicare Supplement 2027: the 1850 insurer that closed Medigap to new buyers in April 2025, its B++ rating, owners and Tennessee rate filings.

Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement: Common Questions for 2027

➤ Is Mutual of Omaha a good Medicare Supplement company?

It is rated A+ (Superior) by AM Best and draws fewer complaints than average. The usual drawback is price, so compare its premium after discounts with other carriers.

➤ What states does Mutual of Omaha sell Medicare Supplement plans in?

Every state except Massachusetts, plus Washington, D.C. Some plan letters are not sold in every state.

➤ Which company actually issues my Mutual of Omaha Medigap policy?

It may be Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company, United of Omaha Life, United World Life or Omaha Insurance Company. Check page one of your policy.

➤ Did Mutual of Omaha’s 2026 reorganization change my Medigap coverage?

No. The April 1, 2026 move to a mutual holding company changed who owns the insurer, not your policy’s benefits or premium rules.

➤ How much is the Mutual of Omaha household discount?

It is 7% or 12%, depending on the state. In many states living with another adult qualifies, not only a spouse.

➤ Does Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement include a gym membership?

Not for free. Mutually Well offers gym access for $29.99 a month, along with vision and hearing discounts. The perks are not available in New York.

➤ Can I buy Plan F from Mutual of Omaha in 2027?

Only if you were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020, and only where Mutual of Omaha still sells it.

➤ How many complaints does Mutual of Omaha get?

Fewer than expected for its size. In Missouri, its four insurers combined for seven Medigap complaints in 2023, a combined index near 58 against an average of 100.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll