Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Philadelphia American Medicare Supplement 2027: Ratings, Plan M and What New Jersey's Rate Chart Reveals

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 8, 2026

Key Takeaway

Philadelphia American Medicare Supplement plans are issued by Philadelphia American Life Insurance Company, a Houston, Texas subsidiary of New Era Life Insurance Company rated A- (Excellent) by AM Best. It is one of the few insurers still filing Plan M, and New Jersey’s September 2026 rate chart shows it with the cheapest High-Deductible Plan G in that state.

2027 by the Numbers

A-

AM Best financial strength, affirmed July 2026 with the outlook cut to negative (AM Best)

$50.83

Monthly High-Deductible G, male 65, lowest of 12 listings on New Jersey’s Sept. 2026 chart (NJ DHS)

$404M

Net premiums, about 83% from individual health coverage (Weiss Ratings, Nov. 2025)

NY, RI

The only states where it is not licensed, plus Puerto Rico (Weiss Ratings)

The name suggests a Pennsylvania insurer, but Philadelphia American Life Insurance Company works out of an office tower on Houston’s Katy Freeway. It belongs to the privately held New Era group, and most people first see the name on a broker’s comparison sheet.

This review leans on public records: AM Best’s rating actions, Weiss Ratings’ financial profile and New Jersey’s state rate chart. Together they show where the company is priced aggressively, where it is not, and why its Plan M filing deserves a look.

Compare Philadelphia American with other Medicare Supplement insurers

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Philadelphia American at a Glance: A Houston Insurer Inside the New Era Group

Philadelphia American Life Insurance Company snapshot: NAIC 67784, Houston Texas, AM Best A- with negative outlook, licensed everywhere except New York and Rhode Island

Philadelphia American Life Insurance Company carries NAIC company code 67784 and lists its office at 11720 Katy Freeway, Suite 1700, Houston, Texas. AM Best describes it as a wholly owned life insurance subsidiary of New Era Life Insurance Company, alongside a third affiliate, New Era Life Insurance Company of the Midwest.

The parent traces its roots to a Texas charter in 1924. New Era says it reopened under new management in 1991, added a Medicare Supplement line in the mid-1990s and grew into one of the larger Medigap writers within a decade. Weiss Ratings’ late-2025 profile shows $404 million in net premiums, roughly 83% from individual health coverage, so Medigap is central here.

New Era also sells Medigap under its own name; the policy you receive names the issuing company, and your state decides which affiliate files there.

Ratings Check: AM Best's July 2026 Outlook Change

In May 2022 AM Best raised the group’s financial strength rating to A- (Excellent) from B++ (Good), citing a strong balance sheet and very strong risk-adjusted capital. Several consumer reviews still print the old B++ grade, so a quote sheet and a website can disagree.

On July 10, 2026, AM Best affirmed the A- rating for all three New Era companies but revised the outlook to negative from stable. Its stated reasons were investment risk: commercial mortgage loans well above the industry average and an above-average share of below-investment-grade bonds. It also noted weaker health results from higher medical costs.

Rating context: A negative outlook is a signal that a downgrade is possible over the next rating cycle, not a downgrade itself. Weiss Ratings, on its own scale, rated the company C in November 2025. Claims on a Medigap policy are also backed by each state’s life and health guaranty association, within that state’s limits.

What New Jersey's Rate Chart Shows About Philadelphia American

New Jersey September 2026 monthly High-Deductible Plan G premiums for a man age 65: Philadelphia American $50.83, Humana Value $53.49, Bankers Life $56.26, Bankers Fidelity $57.02, United World $58.51 and Healthspring $92.08

New Jersey’s Division of Aging Services posts monthly age-65 premiums for every Medigap insurer in the state. Its September 2026 chart for men splits Philadelphia American into two price zones, listed Newark ZIP codes and everywhere else:

Plan Philadelphia American, most NJ ZIPs Newark ZIPs Lowest rate on the chart
High-Deductible G $50.83 $55.91 Philadelphia American (Humana Value $53.49 next)
Plan M $134.67 $148.14 Only insurer listing Plan M
Plan A $181.97 $200.16 United World Life $148.91
Plan N $182.15 $200.37 Bankers Life $119.90
Plan D $220.43 $242.48 Bankers Fidelity $171.63
Plan G Not listed Not listed 19 listings show a Plan G rate

Source: New Jersey Department of Human Services, Male Preferred Rates, Monthly Premium at Age 65, September 2026. Women, older applicants and tobacco users pay different amounts, so treat it as a ranking tool, not a quote.

Reading the chart: Newark-area buyers pay about 10% more than the rest of the state for every Philadelphia American letter. Its Plan N sits $62.25 a month above the cheapest Plan N, while its High-Deductible G undercuts the 11 other listings for that plan.

Get a Plan M, Plan N or High-Deductible G quote

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-888-891-0229

Why Plan M Stands Out on a Philadelphia American Quote

Plan M is one of the least-sold Medigap letters, and no other New Jersey insurer posts a rate for it. It pays half of the Part A hospital deductible, all Part B coinsurance and 80% of emergency care abroad, but leaves you the Part B deductible and any Part B excess charges.

✔
It beats the company’s own Plan N on price. At $134.67 a month, Plan M runs $47.48 below Philadelphia American’s Plan N, or $569.76 a year, in most New Jersey ZIP codes.
✔
No office copays. Plan N can charge up to $20 per doctor visit and $50 for some ER visits; Plan M has neither copay.
✔
The trade-off is the hospital deductible. A hospital stay leaves you half of the Part A deductible.
✔
Excess charges remain. New Jersey is not among the states that bar them, so check whether your doctors accept Medicare assignment. Compare all letters in our guide to Medicare Supplement plans.

Questions? Talk to a Licensed Agent

We compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies at no cost to you.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll

High-Deductible G: Running the Numbers for 2027

Philadelphia American’s lowest-priced New Jersey filing is High-Deductible Plan G, whose deductible is $3,050 in 2027. A worked example for a 65-year-old man outside Newark, using the September 2026 chart:

1
Yearly premium. $50.83 times 12 is $609.96.
2
Worst case. Add the full $3,050 deductible and the most you would pay for covered care is $3,659.96 for the year.
3
Compare a full plan. Philadelphia American’s Plan D costs $220.43 a month, or $2,645.16 a year, before the Part B deductible you still pay under D.
4
Find your break-even. If the bills that count toward the deductible stay under about $2,035 in a year, the high-deductible plan costs less than Plan D’s premium alone.

These are filed 2026 rates, not a promise of 2027 prices.

Plan Letters, Licensing and How Policies Are Sold

Weiss Ratings lists Philadelphia American as licensed in every state except New York and Rhode Island. A license is not an active Medigap filing, and consumer reviews disagree on the national plan menu. New Jersey’s chart confirms A, D, M, N and High-Deductible G there, with no Plan G.

Policies are sold through licensed agents rather than a consumer storefront. New Era says it introduced telephone-interview underwriting and non-tobacco rates in 2007, and applications may include that kind of phone interview. For existing policies, Weiss lists the Houston office line as (281) 368-7200; the number printed on your policy or ID card is the better first call.

Ask before you sign: Confirm three things in writing: which plan letters your state allows, whether rates are set by attained age, issue age or community rating, and whether a household discount applies. Public sources do not settle these terms; our Medicare Supplement household discount guide explains how those rules vary.

Before You Apply: Health Questions, Waiting Periods and Rate Changes

Outside your six-month Medicare Supplement open enrollment window, or a guaranteed issue right, Philadelphia American may ask health questions and decline the application, as any Medigap insurer may. Review typical Medigap underwriting questions first, and if you have a recent diagnosis read our page on Medicare Supplement pre-existing conditions.

Future pricing is the larger unknown, and AM Best’s note on rising medical costs points to premium pressure. State insurance departments post approved filings; Tennessee’s keeps a running list by company. Our Medicare Supplement rate increases guide explains how filings work and what a typical year looks like.

Where Philadelphia American Fits Among Medigap Insurers

New Era group and Philadelphia American rating history: New Era founded 1924, Medicare Supplement line in the mid-1990s, AM Best upgrade to A- in May 2022 and negative outlook in July 2026

Philadelphia American suits buyers who want Plan M, or who are comfortable with a high deductible where its High-Deductible G is priced low. It fits less well for anyone who wants Plan G in New Jersey or the strongest possible rating.

Each letter’s benefits are fixed by federal law, so the comparison comes down to price, rate trend and service. For a larger carrier with a wider letter menu and its own state rate test, see our United American Medicare Supplement review, then compare the field in our ranking of the best Medicare Supplement companies.

Keep Reading

Allstate Medicare Supplement 2027: why Allstate stopped selling new Medigap policies, which company backs existing ones and three straight 24.9% Iowa rate changes.

Philadelphia American Medicare Supplement FAQs

➤ Is Philadelphia American the same company as New Era Life?

No. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of New Era Life Insurance Company, sharing its AM Best rating and Houston base.

➤ Why do some websites still list Philadelphia American as B++?

AM Best upgraded the group from B++ (Good) to A- (Excellent) in May 2022. Pages never updated still show the older grade.

➤ Can I buy Plan G from Philadelphia American in New Jersey?

Not according to the state’s September 2026 rate chart, which lists no Plan G rate for the company. Its closest options there are Plan D and High-Deductible G.

➤ Who should consider Plan M?

People who want lower premiums than Plan N without doctor-visit copays and who can absorb half of the Part A deductible if hospitalized. Philadelphia American is the only New Jersey insurer listing it.

➤ Is Philadelphia American based in Philadelphia?

No. Its office is at 11720 Katy Freeway in Houston, Texas. Despite the name, the company has no Pennsylvania headquarters.

➤ Can New York or Rhode Island residents buy a policy?

Weiss Ratings shows the company is not licensed in either state. Residents there would need a different insurer.

➤ Does my New Jersey ZIP code change the premium?

Yes. The state chart shows higher Philadelphia American rates, about 10% more, for a list of Newark ZIP codes than for the rest of New Jersey.

➤ How do I contact Philadelphia American about my policy?

Use the phone number on your policy or ID card. Weiss Ratings lists the company’s Houston office at (281) 368-7200.

Free Medigap Price Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No cost, no obligation to enroll